When University of Idaho murder suspect Bryan Kohberger was arrested, Hayley Willette could not believe her eyes. Willette says they met on Tinder in 2015 when they were both psychology majors at Pennsylvania colleges. Kohberger took her to a movie and then insisted on escorting her to her dorm room. Creeped out by Kohberger, Willette pretended to throw up in the bathroom hoping to gross him out so he would leave.